So how do you play?
At the beginning of the game you will receive a red or blue token with your role. If your token is blue you are on the “good” team, if red, you are on the “evil” team. Each role is important in its own way. If you are good, you will be either Townsfolk (who have abilities that help solve the game or protect the town) or an Outsider (their abilities tend to interfere with the abilities of Townsfolk, even though they are on the good team, making it just a little more of a fun challenge). If you are evil, you will either be a Demon or a Minion. Minions sow chaos by creating misinformation for town or causing unexpected deaths. Demons (usually) get to kill players throughout the game. The good team wins if they execute the demon. The evil team wins if there are only two players left (and one is the demon).
The game alternates between night and day phases. At night some players are woken up to use their ability or to gain information. (This is based on your role, not the arbitrary judgment of the Storyteller.) During the day, players may talk with each other, either publicly or in private conversations. Nearly everyone has an incentive to lie, to some extent, so don’t believe everything you hear!
After a few minutes of “day,” the Storyteller will call everyone back to Town Square where you can openly discuss what you’ve learned and nominate players for execution. The accuser gives a reason for executing, the nominated player has an opportunity to defend themselves. Then the town votes. If you are executed, don’t feel bad, though. A lot of good can come from it, and you’re still an active part of the game. In fact, most games are decided by the actions and votes of the dead players.
If you ever have a question about your role, or the role you are bluffing, or just want some general strategy advice, be sure to talk to your Storyteller! New players may be afraid it looks suspicious, but it really does not. Many of the most experienced players will have several conversations with the Storyteller each game.